>> Go back to Euro Tax Flash homepage
On June 7, 2017, ministers and other high-level representatives of 67 countries representing 68 jurisdictions signed the Multilateral Convention (PDF 276 KB) (“Multilateral Instrument” or “MLI”) to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) and improve dispute resolution mechanisms. Eight other countries and jurisdictions have expressed their intention to sign the MLI and more countries are expected to sign by the end of this year.
The MLI will only enter into force three months after five jurisdictions have deposited their instrument of ratification, acceptance or approval. More than 1,100 bilateral tax treaties have already been matched and will be modified by the MLI once the respective signatories ratify the instrument in accordance with their domestic procedures. The MLI provisions will generally take effect with respect to withholding taxes on the first day of the calendar year following the last date on which the MLI enters into force for each of the two Contracting Jurisdictions and six months as of this date with respect to all other covered taxes.
More than 100 jurisdictions (the Ad hoc Group) worked under a mandate from the G20 to develop the Multilateral Instrument with the aim of implementing the tax treaty related recommendations from the OECD BEPS Action Plan, including those on hybrid mismatches (Action 2), treaty abuse (Action 6), permanent establishments (Action 7) and dispute resolution mechanisms (Action 14) (see ETF 218 (PDF 149 KB)), into their existing bilateral tax treaties.
Following the adoption of the MLI and its accompanying Explanatory Statement (PDF 556 KB) on November 24, 2016, (see ETF 305), interested jurisdictions were able to indicate how they wanted to incorporate the MLI into their existing tax treaties, i.e. their choices with respect to the different options available under the MLI – the “MLI position (PDF 127 KB)”.
A high-level ceremony was held on June 7, 2017, in Paris, where representatives of 68 jurisdictions signed the MLI, while others expressed their intention to join in the near future. Signatories are granted flexibility in meeting BEPS minimum standards on treaty shopping and dispute resolution and the possibility to opt out of provisions that do not reflect a minimum standard. The MLI Position submitted by each signatory prior to the signing ceremony includes a list of tax treaties they wish to modify using the MLI and their options and reservations. A total of 2,362 treaties have been listed by the signatories – treaties for which the two jurisdictions have sent notification of their intention to modify the agreement using the MLI (“Covered Tax Agreements”), with 1,103 treaties already matched (the two parties choose to apply the same optional provisions) and expected to be modified by the MLI.
The Principal Purposes Test introduced under BEPS Action 6 will apply to all treaties covered by the MLI, while an additional simplified Limitation on Benefits test will only apply to the treaties of 12 jurisdictions, including Argentina, Armenia, Bulgaria, Chile, Colombia, India, Indonesia, Mexico, Russia, Senegal, the Slovak Republic and Uruguay.
So far, 25 signatories have signed up for the mandatory binding arbitration mechanism provided for in the MLI: Andorra, Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Fiji, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Portugal, Singapore, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and the United Kingdom. It is expected that arbitration will be introduced in over 150 existing treaties, with most countries opting for the final offer arbitration mechanism (also referred to as “baseball arbitration”). Signatories can modify their MLI Positions until ratification and are required to notify subsequent changes to their MLI position to the OECD before they can become effective. Therefore, additional jurisdictions can choose to introduce mandatory arbitration in their treaties at a later date.
The Multilateral Instrument will only enter into force three months after five countries have ratified, accepted or approved it. Once ratified, the MLI provisions chosen can potentially apply to all the Covered Tax Agreements specified by the countries, although a specific Covered Tax Agreement will only enter into force after the parties to that treaty have ratified the MLI. The OECD expects the first modifications to covered treaties to become effective during the course of next year.
The MLI does not override or amend existing bilateral tax treaties – as an amending protocol does – but is applied alongside the Covered Tax Agreements, modifying their application in order to implement BEPS measures. Even if there is no domestic legal requirement to prepare consolidated texts of modified treaties, jurisdictions may choose to prepare consolidated versions. Meanwhile, the OECD is developing tools to facilitate the application of the MLI to existing treaties.
Implementation of the four BEPS minimum standards (two of which – on treaty shopping and dispute resolution – are relevant in the context of the MLI) is subject to peer review. Members (PDF 96 KB) of the Inclusive Framework for BEPS Implementation have committed to implementing the minimum standards and are subject to the peer reviews. The first report on compliance with the minimum standard to address treaty shopping contained in Action 6 is expected to be issued by January 1, 2019. In order to meet the minimum standard on time, the countries signing the MLI may have to accelerate the ratification process.
The MLI is open for signature by all other jurisdictions, some of which are currently working to prepare for signature
The signing of the MLI is a historic step in the fight against treaty abuse and treaty shopping, but also with regard to best practices in the area of dispute resolution. The practical effects of its implementation will depend on the choices and reservations made by the signatories and how tax administrations apply the new provisions in practice. The tools and resources to be developed by the OECD will likely be an essential part of that process.
Should you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact KPMG’s EU Tax Centre, or, as appropriate, your local KPMG tax advisor.