This proposal is part of the Commission’s corporate tax package published on October 25, 2016.
This proposal is part of the Commission’s corporate tax package published on October 25, 2016 (see ETF 303) and is foreseen as an amendment to the EU Anti-tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD1). (See ETF 289)
The adoption of ATAD2 was a high priority for the previous Slovak Presidency, but on December 6, 2016 EU Member States were not yet in a position to reach an agreement. The main points of the discussion were the scope of the carve-out options and the implementation date of the proposal. (See ETF 306) The delegations have now agreed on these substantive issues.
Hybrid mismatches occur when countries have different rules for the tax treatment of certain income or entities. ATAD1 applies to hybrid mismatches arising from differences in the legal characterisation of a financial instrument or entity, and provides that, if a hybrid mismatch results in a double deduction, a deduction shall only be provided in the source state of the payment, and if it results in a deduction without inclusion, the deduction shall be denied. The compromise agreement changes these rules, in particular by introducing ‘secondary rules’, to cover the possibility that the state in question does not apply the main, or ‘primary’ rules.
Contrary to the initial plans of the European Commission, ATAD1 covered only intra-EU situations. The ATAD2 compromise extends the scope of these rules to hybrid mismatches between EU Member States and third countries.
The compromise agreement also extends the scope of the hybrid situations that are covered by ATAD1. In particular, ATAD 2 would also apply to the following situations: reverse hybrids, income allocation mismatches and deemed payments involving permanent establishments, hybrid permanent establishments, imported mismatches, hybrid transfers resulting in multiple relief for withholding tax, and dual residency resulting in double deductions.
According to the compromise agreement there is a carve-out option up to December 31, 2022 for hybrid regulatory capital in the banking sector. There is also a carve-out for financial traders involving hybrid transfers made in the ordinary course of business. The general application date of ATAD2 is January 1, 2020. This is one year later than ATAD1, which in most respects shall apply from January 1, 2019. However, a specific provision of ATAD2 in terms of reverse hybrids shall become effective only as from January 1, 2022 in domestic legislation.
The compromise text of the ATAD2 proposal will now be adjusted by the Presidency accordingly and will be submitted to a later ECOFIN meeting for formal adoption once the European Parliament has given its (informal) opinion.
Developing a common EU list of third country tax jurisdictions that do not conform to international good governance tax standards has also been discussed in today’s ECOFIN meeting, and, in line with the outcome of the ECOFIN meeting held last December, the list should be ready by the end of this year. (See ETF 301 and ETF 304)
This compromise agreement represents the end of the political discussions on how to implement the OECD’s work on hybrid mismatches into a common EU set of rules. The practical implications for existing and future arrangements will need to be carefully addressed once the final text has been published.